• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Immigration Law of Montana

Christopher J. Flann, Attorney

406-373-9828
  • Make an Appointment
  • Client Log In
  • Home

Immigration Law of Montana

  • About
    • How to Read Immigration Lawyer Reviews
    • Christopher Flann, Attorney
    • Collette Layton, Legal Assistant
    • Rockwell “Rock” Hinkle, Legal Assistant
    • Reviews and Testimonials
    • Gabriela Veroes Legal Assistant
    • Maryangel Aguilera Legal Assistant
    • Fidel Villegas, Legal Assistant
    • Gabriel Chávez, Legal Assistant
  • US Citizenship
    • Form N-648 Medical Disability Exception
    • Age-Based English Waivers
    • N-600 vs Passport for Citizenship Proof
    • INA 320 — Automatic Citizenship
    • Stepchild Adoption and Citizenship
    • Citizenship through Adoption
    • Citizenship through Naturalization
    • The 3-Year Rule for Spouses
    • When the 3-Year Clock Starts
    • Separation and the 3-Year Rule
    • Citizenship through Military
    • Derivative US Citizenship
    • Child Born Abroad: Check Citizenship Before the I-130
    • N-600K — Citizenship Through a Grandparent
    • INA 301 & 309 — Citizenship at Birth Abroad
  • Green Cards
    • I-130 Separate Petitions for LPRs
    • Income Requirements with Stepchildren
    • AOS with 10-Year Bar (212(d)(3))
    • I-751 Waiver After Divorce
    • Refugee Travel Document Expired
    • Protecting Asylum / SIJS Benefits
    • Asylee Adjustment: INA 209 vs 245
    • NVC Document Roadblocks
    • 221(g) Refusal Explained
    • F-2B Election (Parent Naturalizes)
    • VAWA for Cuban Adjustment Act Derivatives
    • Lying on Form I-485
    • Adjustment of Status: Getting Your Green Card Without Leaving the United States
    • Health and the Public Charge Test
    • Asylee Green Card
    • Conditional Green Card Renewal: Removing Conditions With Form I-751
    • Employment Based Green Card
    • O-1 to a Green Card
    • I-140 Ability to Pay
    • Ability to Pay After a Loss Year
    • Consular Processing
    • Family Based Green Card
    • Green Card for Religious Worker
    • Green Card through Marriage
    • Green Card through Refugee or Asylee Status
    • Parole in Place for Military Families (2026): Who Qualifies, How to Apply, and What It Costs
    • Green Card Renewal: Complete I-90 Guide
    • Humanitarian Green Card
    • Refugee Green Card
    • Sheepherder Green Card
    • H-2A Range Workers to Green Cards
    • Marrying an Illegal Immigrant
    • For American Indians Born in Canada
    • Special Immigrant Visa
    • When Your LPR Spouse Dies
    • When Your USC Spouse Dies
    • Derivative Beneficiaries When Petitioners Die
  • Immigration Guides
    • Lying on Immigration Forms
    • PERM: Education + Experience
    • The EB-4 Visa Problem
    • Rights of Filipino Teachers and Workers
    • Canadian Immigration Pathways
    • Immigration for Employers
    • EB-5 Investor Visa Guide
    • Immigration for Farmers and Ranchers
    • Immigration for Religious Organizations
    • Farm Worker Green Cards
  • US Visas
    • J-1 Exchange Visitor Visa
      • J-1 Intern & Trainee Year
      • J-1 Summer Work Travel
      • J-1 Au Pair Program
      • J-1 Two-Year Home-Residency Rule
      • J-1 Waivers
      • Conrad 30 for J-1 Physicians
      • J-1 Advisory Opinion
      • After Your J-1 Year
      • J-1 or F-1 for Married Students
    • B-1 for Religious Work
    • Performer Visa Requirements
    • Options After Parole Termination
    • Asylum: Complete Application Guide
    • Asylum for Visa Waiver Program Entrants
    • Withdrawing a Preparer-Filed Asylum Application
    • F-1 & OPT
      • STEM OPT Extension Guide
      • OPT Guide for F-1 Students
    • E-Series Visas
      • E-3 Job Ended: Your Options
      • E-2 Business Changes
      • E-2 Visa for Canadians
      • E-1 Visa for Treaty Traders
      • E-2 Visa for Treaty Investors
        • The E-2 Active-Investment Standard
        • E-2 Investor: You or Your Company?
        • L-1A New Office to EB-1C Green Card
        • E-2 Renewal RFE and Deference
      • E-3 Visa for Australian Professionals
    • H-1B Repayment Agreements
    • TN Catch-All Categories
    • The B-2 Visitor Visa: A Practical Guide
    • B-1 Visa for Business Visitors
    • H-1B Visa for Specialty Occupation Workers
      • H-1B Visa Lottery
      • H-1B for School Districts
        • Cap exemption for school districts
        • Teacher job descriptions and RFEs
      • H-1B Cap-Gap & OPT
    • H-2A Program
      • H-2A Wage Rates
      • H-2A Job Service Referrals
      • DUI and the H-2A Visa
      • Canadian Custom Combine Crews (H-2A)
      • H-2A Mobile Housing
      • H-2A Workers Staying Longer
      • H-2A Ended, Asylum Pending: Working in the Gap
      • Becoming an H-2A Labor Contractor
      • H-2A Seasonality Requirements
    • H-2B Visa Guide: Cap, Lottery, and Temporary Need
    • H-3 Visa for Trainees and Special Education Visitors
    • K-1 Visa
      • K-1 and Expedited Removal
      • K-1 Meeting Waiver
      • K-1 with Criminal Record
    • K-3 Spouse Visa
    • O-1 Visa for Artists, Scientists, Educators, Businesspeople and Athletes
    • P-3 Visa: A Guide to Culturally Unique Programs
    • R-1 Visa for Religious Workers
    • R-1 Five-Year Limit: Recapturing Time
    • TN Visa: Work Authorization Under USMCA
    • Canadian Nurse Practitioners on a TN
    • U Visa for Crime Victims: What It Takes and What to Expect
    • T Visa for Trafficking Victims
    • Change of Nonimmigrant Status
    • Form I-539 (2026): Extending or Changing Your Nonimmigrant Status
    • Process for US Visa Application Through Admission and Stay
    • Entry into United States
    • I-94 Admission Record: What Controls Your Stay
    • CBP Travel History Shows Trips You Never Took
    • Refused Re-Entry After a Canada Trip
    • Volunteer Visa USA
    • Humanitarian Parole: Programs, Termination & Options
    • Leaving the United States
  • Immigration Services
    • Premium Processing Eligibility
    • How to Withdraw a Pending USCIS Application
    • RFE Response Help in Montana: When Immigration Requests Can Be Fixed (And When They Can’t)
    • Apostille Services
    • Document Translation Services
    • Picked Up by ICE in Montana: What to Do, Where They Will Be Held, and What Comes Next
    • Why A Strategy Consultation
  • Removal Defense
    • Removal Proceedings Overview
    • Picked Up by ICE in Montana
    • Detention & Bond Hearings
    • Get Your Immigration Court Records
    • Get Your USCIS Records
    • Pull Your Criminal Record
    • Criminal Records & Immigration Status
    • Everyday Offenses
    • Cancellation of Removal
      • Non-LPR Cancellation
      • VAWA Cancellation
      • BIA Ends Easy LPR Cancellation
    • Withholding of Removal
    • Convention Against Torture (CAT)
    • Country Conditions Expert
    • Adjustment of Status in Immigration Court
    • SIJS Green Card in Immigration Court
    • Marriage During Removal Proceedings
    • Green Card Never Valid
    • In Absentia Removal Orders
    • Appeals & Motions
    • Voluntary Departure & CBP Home
  • Waivers
    • I-601A Provisional Waiver
    • Before Your Consular Interview
    • I-212 Permission to Reapply
    • Denied Entry to the USA
    • Canadian Rehabilitation
    • Green Card Never Valid
    • AOS with a 10-Year Bar after 212(d)(3)
    • Unlawful Presence
  • Federal Court
    • My Case Is Stuck: Can I Sue USCIS?
  • Service Area
    • Immigration Lawyer in Montana
    • Immigration Lawyer North Dakota
    • Immigration Lawyer Wyoming
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • EnglishEnglish
    • EspañolEspañol
You are here: Home / US Visa Types: A Guide / H-2A Visa for Farm and Ranch Employers: How It Works / Job Service Sent U.S. Workers to Your H-2A Job: What Now?

Job Service Sent U.S. Workers to Your H-2A Job: What Now?

A single line of boot prints in fresh snow leads to the closed door of a ranch bunkhouse on the plains.

Picture the call. Your H-2A job order has been accepted, the labor certification application is pending, and the state job service has just sent you two local applicants. You did not ask for them, you were not planning to hire them, and they may have applied only because the unemployment office told them to. The question that follows is a natural one: Do I really have to deal with these people, or can I just pull the H-2A application and start over?

The short answer (checked November 9, 2026). You have to contact every U.S. worker the job service refers. You may interview them, but only by phone or close to where they live, and only if you interview your H-2A workers the same way. You have to hire every referral who is qualified under the requirements in your job order and available for the job from the date they would start through the end date. You may turn one down only for a lawful, job-related reason, and you have to write that reason in your recruitment report. Withdrawing the application does not get you out of this. The duties to workers already recruited survive withdrawal, and anything you failed to do during recruitment stays a violation.

Flowchart: a job service referral arrives; contact the worker and log each attempt; if no response, record it; if the worker responds, check availability and the job order's requirements; hire if qualified, otherwise record a job-related reason; every referral goes on the recruitment report.

Why did the state job service send me applicants for my H-2A job?

Because sending them is the job service’s role in the H-2A program. Every H-2A job order goes to the state workforce agency (in most states called the job service), which places it for local recruitment, and DOL sends it to other states for “interstate clearance.” The regulation tells each of those agencies to keep the order active until the end of the recruitment period and to “refer each qualified U.S. worker who applies” (20 CFR 655.150(b)). The H-2A program rests on a promise in the statute: labor certification is granted only when there are not enough able, willing and qualified workers available at the time and place needed, and hiring H-2A workers will not depress the wages and working conditions of workers here (8 U.S.C. 1188(a)(1)). A referral is how that promise gets tested.

A referral also comes with a statement from the worker. The job service may refer only people who have been told the material terms of the job and who, by accepting the referral, have indicated that they are “qualified, able, willing, and available” (20 CFR 655.155). So you cannot treat a referral as someone who is obviously not interested. The burden runs the other way: the worker has said yes, and your file has to show what happened next.

Many referrals come from the unemployment system. In some states one agency runs both unemployment insurance and the job service. North Dakota is an example: Job Service North Dakota administers both the state unemployment law and the state employment service (N.D.C.C. 52-02-01). State unemployment law generally requires a claimant to be available for and actively seeking work, and a claimant who without good cause fails to apply for or accept suitable work when directed can lose benefits (in North Dakota, N.D.C.C. 52-06-01(3) and 52-06-02(3)). In our experience (as of November 2026), that is why a job order can draw applicants who are meeting a work-search requirement as much as looking for a farm job, and in our experience most referrals arrive soon after a job order first posts, not months into the season. Neither observation changes what you owe the worker. A referral who applied “for the unemployment” is still a U.S. worker who applied.

Do I have to contact and interview a Job Service referral?

You have to contact the referral. You do not have to interview. By filing, the employer promised to “cooperate with the SWA by accepting referrals of all eligible U.S. workers who apply” until the end of the recruitment period (20 CFR 655.135(c)(1)), and to “consider all U.S. applicants” and “accept and hire all applicants who are qualified and who will be available” (20 CFR 655.135(c)(3)). Nothing in the rules makes a hire depend on an interview.

If you want an interview, the rule sets two limits. Put in plain terms, 20 CFR 655.135(c)(2) says an employer that requires interviews must hold them by phone, or arrange them where the U.S. worker is being recruited, so the worker bears little or no cost; and an employer may not give potential H-2A workers more favorable treatment than U.S. workers in whether, or how, it interviews them. That second limit catches employers by surprise. If your returning H-2A worker was rehired without an interview, demanding a formal interview of the local referral is the kind of unequal treatment the rule forbids. If you video-call your H-2A candidates for twenty minutes, a twenty-minute phone call with the referral is the matching treatment.

What the published cases punish is silence. In Administrator, Wage & Hour Division v. Fernandez Farms, Inc., ALJ No. 2014-TAE-00008 (Aug. 25, 2016), the state agency’s records showed that five workers had been referred to the farm, and the employer “did not follow up with the workers or offer jobs to the workers.” The judge found the rejections unlawful and ordered back wages to the five referrals totaling $51,911.21. The employer’s argument that the referrals had not followed through failed because nothing in its file showed it.

How do I interview a referred U.S. worker without creating a problem?

Ask only what the job order asks, ask it the same way you ask your H-2A candidates, and write down the answers. A short phone call usually covers it. What follows is how we advise employers to run it (as of November 2026), built on the rules above:

  • Reach out promptly, more than once, and log each try. Call, then text or email if there is no answer. Note the date, time, number and result of each attempt. There is no regulation that sets a number of attempts; we recommend at least two, a few days apart, because “no response” is a lawful disposition only if you can show you tried.
  • Describe the job as the job order describes it: duties, location, hours, the wage, housing if offered, the start date and the end date.
  • Ask about availability. “Can you start on the date we need you and work through the end date?” is a fair question to every applicant.
  • Ask only about requirements that are in the job order. If the job order asks for three months of experience operating a tractor, you can ask about that experience. If it does not mention a commercial driver’s license, horse experience or a lifting limit, you cannot use one to turn someone down.
  • Do not ask about unemployment benefits, and do not treat a work-search referral as less serious than any other applicant.
  • Write down the outcome the same day: hired, declined the offer, did not respond, not available for the period, or does not meet a stated requirement (name it).

An employer that adds requirements of its own at the interview stage takes a real risk. In In re Three D Farms, LLC, ALJ No. 2016-TAE-00003 (Aug. 18, 2016), the employer gave state-referred applicants a questionnaire that asked about matters the job order did not require, such as a pesticide applicator license, lifting 100 pounds when the job order said 60, and knowledge of local roads, and then rejected applicants on those grounds. The judge upheld a $7,500 civil money penalty. (Back wages were denied only because the worker had found another job before the season began.)

When can I lawfully turn a referral down?

Only for a lawful, job-related reason that you apply to everyone. The rule says it twice: rejections of U.S. workers “must be only for lawful, job-related reasons,” and those not rejected on that basis must be hired (20 CFR 655.135(a), (c)(3)). The requirements themselves must be bona fide and normal for employers in the same crops who do not use H-2A workers (20 CFR 655.122(b)), and you may not impose on U.S. workers any requirement you do not impose on your H-2A workers (20 CFR 655.122(a)).

Reasons that usually hold up, when documented:

  • The worker did not respond after documented attempts to reach him.
  • The worker declined the job when it was offered.
  • The worker is not available for the job from the date he would start through the end date in the job order.
  • The worker does not meet a requirement that is written in the job order and that your H-2A workers also had to meet.

Reasons that do not hold up:

  • “He only applied to keep his unemployment.”
  • “I already have my H-2A crew picked out,” or “my returning worker is better.”
  • A requirement that is not in the job order, or one your H-2A workers did not have to meet. In the 2023 Washington Farm Labor Association case, the job description required three months of experience, U.S. applicants were turned away for lacking it, and many of the H-2A workers hired did not have it; the Administrative Review Board affirmed the penalties (ALJ No. 2018-TAE-00013 (Aug. 25, 2021), aff’d, ARB No. 2021-0069 (Mar. 31, 2023)).
  • Anything tied to race, color, national origin, age, sex, religion, disability or citizenship status (20 CFR 655.135(a)).

What happens if I hire the U.S. worker?

If you hire before DOL decides your application, you need one fewer H-2A worker, and the U.S. worker gets at least the same terms. When the Department of Labor decides your application, it reduces the number of H-2A workers certified by one for each U.S. worker who is able, willing, qualified and available and was not rejected for a lawful, job-related reason (20 CFR 655.165). A U.S. worker hired after certification, under the 50 percent rule described below, is hired in addition to your H-2A crew.

The U.S. worker is entitled to no less than the wages, benefits and working conditions you offer the H-2A workers (20 CFR 655.122(a)). That includes the three-fourths guarantee and, under the 2025 wage rule, the U.S.-worker rate, which is higher than the H-2A rate in the same job; our guide to H-2A wage rates has the current figures. Free housing is owed to a U.S. worker in the same job who cannot reasonably return home each night (20 CFR 655.122(d)(1)).

Hiring a referral is not a lifetime commitment. Under the rule DOL applies today (as of November 2026, the 2024 version of this paragraph is blocked by a court order in Montana and North Dakota, among other states, and the Wage and Hour Division suspended enforcement of the 2024 rule nationwide in June 2025 while DOL works on rescinding it), if a worker abandons the job or is terminated for cause and you notify the National Processing Center in writing within 2 working days, you are not responsible for that worker’s later transportation and subsistence costs or the three-fourths guarantee. Abandonment begins after a worker fails to report for 5 consecutive working days without your consent (20 CFR 655.122(n) (text as of June 27, 2024)). Keep the notice; the rule requires you to keep it for 3 years.

Can I withdraw my H-2A application instead?

You can withdraw, but withdrawal does not undo what the referral triggered. Which rule applies depends on where the case stands:

  • Job order filed, application not yet filed: 20 CFR 655.124.
  • Application filed but not yet decided: 20 CFR 655.136. This is the usual posture when a job service referral arrives.
  • Application already certified: 20 CFR 655.172.

All three say the same two things. The request must be in writing to the National Processing Center and must state the reasons. And the employer “is still obligated to comply with the terms and conditions of employment” in the job order “with respect to all workers recruited in connection with” it. When DOL reorganized these rules in 2022, it answered employers who objected to that continuing obligation by saying that “these obligations attach at recruitment and continue after withdrawal” (87 FR 61660, 61725 (Oct. 12, 2022)).

Three further problems make withdrawal a poor exit:

  1. The violation has already happened. The debarment rule reaches a failure to offer employment to “qualified U.S. workers who applied for the job opportunity for which certification was sought,” and a failure to comply with the employer’s obligations to recruit U.S. workers (20 CFR 655.182(d)(1)(ii)–(iii)). The words “was sought” are our reason for saying a withdrawn application does not take that exposure away; we know of no decision that holds otherwise.
  2. The written reason is a record. A withdrawal letter that says, in substance, “we withdrew because the state sent us U.S. workers” is evidence that the job was not really open to them. We would not want a client to write that letter.
  3. The job service can stop serving you. Under the version of the rule DOL applies today, state agencies “must initiate procedures for discontinuation of services” to an employer that refuses “to accept qualified workers referred through the clearance system” (20 CFR 658.501(a)(6) (text as of June 27, 2024)). An employer cut off from the job service cannot place the job order that every H-2A application starts with.

Withdrawal is the right step when the need for workers has truly gone away, for example when a crop fails. It is the wrong step when the only thing that has changed is that a U.S. worker applied.

What is debarment, and can one rejected referral lead to it?

Debarment bars an employer, and its successors, from filing H-2A applications for up to 3 years. Two parts of the Department of Labor can impose it. The Office of Foreign Labor Certification can debar an employer that “substantially violated a material term or condition” of the labor certification with respect to H-2A workers, workers in corresponding employment, or “U.S. workers improperly rejected for employment” (20 CFR 655.182(a)). The Wage and Hour Division has a parallel power (29 CFR 501.20). Either must issue the notice of debarment within 2 years of the violation, and no debarment may run longer than 3 years (20 CFR 655.182(c)).

Debarment is not the only remedy, and in the decisions we reviewed it was not the usual one for a rejected referral. The Wage and Hour Division can recover back wages and seek “reinstatement and make whole relief for any U.S. worker who has been improperly rejected for employment” (29 CFR 501.16(a)(1)), and it can assess civil money penalties. As of November 2026 the regulation caps a penalty at $2,166 per violation, or $7,289 per willful violation (29 CFR 501.19(c); the caps are adjusted for inflation each year). Each rejected worker can be a separate violation. In the published decisions we found (as of November 2026), a rejected referral led to back wages or a penalty, and debarment came where an employer had many violations at once. That is a pattern in the cases, not a rule, and the regulation itself names failing to offer employment to a qualified U.S. applicant as a violation that can support debarment.

How is this different from PERM?

H-2A is stricter. Employers who have sponsored a green card through PERM often assume the H-2A rule is the same, and it is not. In PERM, a debarment of up to 3 years rests on grounds such as a pattern or practice of failing to comply with the program’s requirements, or willfully providing false information (20 CFR 656.31(f)(1)). A single PERM recruitment failure ordinarily costs the employer that application. In H-2A, the employer has promised to hire every qualified, available U.S. applicant, and failing to offer one a job is itself a listed violation that can support debarment if DOL finds it substantial (20 CFR 655.182(d)(1)(ii), (e)). Our PERM guide covers the green-card side.

What should go in the recruitment report and the file?

Every referral, with what happened to each. The recruitment report must give the name and contact information of each U.S. worker “who applied or was referred to the job opportunity” and the disposition of each, and for anyone not hired, the lawful job-related reason (20 CFR 655.156(a)). You must keep updating it until the end of the recruitment period (20 CFR 655.156(b)). A referral cannot be made to disappear from that report, and leaving one off is a far more serious problem than the referral itself. Keep everything that backs up the report for 3 years from certification, or from the decision if the application is denied or withdrawn (20 CFR 655.167(b)). In our practice that means:

  • the referral notices from the job service;
  • your contact log (dates, times, numbers, results);
  • notes of any interview, written the same day;
  • offer letters or texts, and any written refusal;
  • the recruitment report and every update to it (20 CFR 655.167(c) lists the report and the material that substantiates it).

In Fernandez Farms, the judge said it is “fair to infer” that an employer that was required to keep documentation of compliance and did not keep it did not comply. Records are what turn “he never called back” from an excuse into a lawful disposition.

How long do referrals keep coming?

Until the H-2A workers leave for your farm, and for larger employers until half the contract has run. Positive recruitment ends when the H-2A workers depart for the place of employment, which the rule presumes is the third day before the first date of need (20 CFR 655.158). After that, the 50 percent rule requires the employer to hire any qualified, eligible U.S. worker who applies until half the contract period has passed (20 CFR 655.135(d)). The 50 percent rule does not apply to an employer that certifies that, in every calendar quarter of the preceding calendar year, it used no more than 500 man-days of agricultural labor; that it is not an employer-member of an association that filed for its members; and that it has not otherwise associated with other employers who are petitioning for H-2A workers. In our experience, many family ranches in Montana fit that exemption, and many larger operations do not. Check which one you are before you plan your crew.

The mistake to avoid

The expensive mistake is not hiring a local worker you did not plan on. It is letting a referral sit, or deciding that the H-2A application is the problem and pulling it. A referral that is contacted, offered the job on the job order’s terms and either hired or turned down for a written, job-related reason costs you little and reduces the number of H-2A workers you need. A referral that is ignored is the case DOL wins.

If you have a job service referral on your desk and a recruitment report due, call us. Immigration Law of Montana, P.C. files H-2A applications for farms and ranches in Montana, North Dakota and Wyoming. Our H-2A program overview covers the rest of the process, and our article on sorting the applications that arrive from SeasonalJobs.dol.gov covers the other inbox an H-2A employer has to manage.

Footer

Our Location

We are located about 20 minutes NE of Billings in a rural community:

Immigration Law of Montana, P.C.
8400 Clark Rd
Shepherd, MT 59079
406-373-9828

Affiliations

Montana State Bar

AILA Member

 

Social

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Tumblr
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Immigration Lawyer Montana
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms of Service
  • Site Map
  • Contact Us

COPYRIGHT © 2026 Immigration Law of Montana · All Rights Reserved

  • EnglishEnglish
  • EspañolEspañol