• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Immigration Law of Montana

Christopher J. Flann, Attorney

406-373-9828
  • Make an Appointment
  • Client Log In
  • Home

Immigration Law of Montana

  • About
    • How to Read Immigration Lawyer Reviews
    • Christopher Flann, Attorney
    • Collette Layton, Legal Assistant
    • Rockwell “Rock” Hinkle, Legal Assistant
    • Reviews and Testimonials
    • Gabriela Veroes Legal Assistant
    • Maryangel Aguilera Legal Assistant
    • Fidel Villegas, Legal Assistant
    • Gabriel Chávez, Legal Assistant
  • US Citizenship
    • Form N-648 Medical Disability Exception
    • Age-Based English Waivers
    • N-600 vs Passport for Citizenship Proof
    • INA 320 — Automatic Citizenship
    • Stepchild Adoption and Citizenship
    • Citizenship through Adoption
    • Citizenship through Naturalization
    • The 3-Year Rule for Spouses
    • When the 3-Year Clock Starts
    • Separation and the 3-Year Rule
    • Citizenship through Military
    • Derivative US Citizenship
    • Child Born Abroad: Check Citizenship Before the I-130
    • N-600K — Citizenship Through a Grandparent
    • INA 301 & 309 — Citizenship at Birth Abroad
  • Green Cards
    • I-130 Separate Petitions for LPRs
    • Income Requirements with Stepchildren
    • AOS with 10-Year Bar (212(d)(3))
    • I-751 Waiver After Divorce
    • Refugee Travel Document Expired
    • Protecting Asylum / SIJS Benefits
    • Asylee Adjustment: INA 209 vs 245
    • NVC Document Roadblocks
    • 221(g) Refusal Explained
    • F-2B Election (Parent Naturalizes)
    • VAWA for Cuban Adjustment Act Derivatives
    • Lying on Form I-485
    • Adjustment of Status: Getting Your Green Card Without Leaving the United States
    • Health and the Public Charge Test
    • Asylee Green Card
    • Conditional Green Card Renewal: Removing Conditions With Form I-751
    • Employment Based Green Card
    • O-1 to a Green Card
    • I-140 Ability to Pay
    • Ability to Pay After a Loss Year
    • Consular Processing
    • Family Based Green Card
    • Green Card for Religious Worker
    • Green Card through Marriage
    • Green Card through Refugee or Asylee Status
    • Parole in Place for Military Families (2026): Who Qualifies, How to Apply, and What It Costs
    • Green Card Renewal: Complete I-90 Guide
    • Humanitarian Green Card
    • Refugee Green Card
    • Sheepherder Green Card
    • H-2A Range Workers to Green Cards
    • Marrying an Illegal Immigrant
    • For American Indians Born in Canada
    • Special Immigrant Visa
    • When Your LPR Spouse Dies
    • When Your USC Spouse Dies
    • Derivative Beneficiaries When Petitioners Die
  • Immigration Guides
    • Lying on Immigration Forms
    • PERM: Education + Experience
    • The EB-4 Visa Problem
    • Rights of Filipino Teachers and Workers
    • Canadian Immigration Pathways
    • Immigration for Employers
    • EB-5 Investor Visa Guide
    • Immigration for Farmers and Ranchers
    • Immigration for Religious Organizations
    • Farm Worker Green Cards
  • US Visas
    • J-1 Exchange Visitor Visa
      • J-1 Intern & Trainee Year
      • J-1 Summer Work Travel
      • J-1 Au Pair Program
      • J-1 Two-Year Home-Residency Rule
      • J-1 Waivers
      • Conrad 30 for J-1 Physicians
      • J-1 Advisory Opinion
      • After Your J-1 Year
      • J-1 or F-1 for Married Students
    • B-1 for Religious Work
    • Performer Visa Requirements
    • Options After Parole Termination
    • Asylum: Complete Application Guide
    • Asylum for Visa Waiver Program Entrants
    • Withdrawing a Preparer-Filed Asylum Application
    • F-1 & OPT
      • STEM OPT Extension Guide
      • OPT Guide for F-1 Students
    • E-Series Visas
      • E-3 Job Ended: Your Options
      • E-2 Business Changes
      • E-2 Visa for Canadians
      • E-1 Visa for Treaty Traders
      • E-2 Visa for Treaty Investors
        • The E-2 Active-Investment Standard
        • E-2 Investor: You or Your Company?
        • E-2 Renewal RFE and Deference
      • E-3 Visa for Australian Professionals
    • H-1B Repayment Agreements
    • TN Catch-All Categories
    • The B-2 Visitor Visa: A Practical Guide
    • B-1 Visa for Business Visitors
    • H-1B Visa for Specialty Occupation Workers
      • H-1B Visa Lottery
      • H-1B for School Districts
        • Cap exemption for school districts
        • Teacher job descriptions and RFEs
      • H-1B Cap-Gap & OPT
    • H-2A Program
      • H-2A Wage Rates
      • DUI and the H-2A Visa
      • Canadian Custom Combine Crews (H-2A)
      • H-2A Mobile Housing
      • H-2A Workers Staying Longer
      • H-2A Ended, Asylum Pending: Working in the Gap
      • Becoming an H-2A Labor Contractor
      • H-2A Seasonality Requirements
    • H-2B Visa Guide: Cap, Lottery, and Temporary Need
    • H-3 Visa for Trainees and Special Education Visitors
    • K-1 Visa
      • K-1 and Expedited Removal
      • K-1 Meeting Waiver
      • K-1 with Criminal Record
    • K-3 Spouse Visa
    • O-1 Visa for Artists, Scientists, Educators, Businesspeople and Athletes
    • P-3 Visa: A Guide to Culturally Unique Programs
    • R-1 Visa for Religious Workers
    • R-1 Five-Year Limit: Recapturing Time
    • TN Visa: Work Authorization Under USMCA
    • Canadian Nurse Practitioners on a TN
    • U Visa for Crime Victims: What It Takes and What to Expect
    • T Visa for Trafficking Victims
    • Change of Nonimmigrant Status
    • Form I-539 (2026): Extending or Changing Your Nonimmigrant Status
    • Process for US Visa Application Through Admission and Stay
    • Entry into United States
    • I-94 Admission Record: What Controls Your Stay
    • CBP Travel History Shows Trips You Never Took
    • Refused Re-Entry After a Canada Trip
    • Volunteer Visa USA
    • Humanitarian Parole: Programs, Termination & Options
    • Leaving the United States
  • Immigration Services
    • Premium Processing Eligibility
    • How to Withdraw a Pending USCIS Application
    • RFE Response Help in Montana: When Immigration Requests Can Be Fixed (And When They Can’t)
    • Apostille Services
    • Document Translation Services
    • Picked Up by ICE in Montana: What to Do, Where They Will Be Held, and What Comes Next
    • Why A Strategy Consultation
  • Removal Defense
    • Removal Proceedings Overview
    • Picked Up by ICE in Montana
    • Detention & Bond Hearings
    • Get Your Immigration Court Records
    • Get Your USCIS Records
    • Pull Your Criminal Record
    • Criminal Records & Immigration Status
    • Everyday Offenses
    • Cancellation of Removal
      • Non-LPR Cancellation
      • VAWA Cancellation
      • BIA Ends Easy LPR Cancellation
    • Withholding of Removal
    • Convention Against Torture (CAT)
    • Country Conditions Expert
    • Adjustment of Status in Immigration Court
    • Marriage During Removal Proceedings
    • Green Card Never Valid
    • In Absentia Removal Orders
    • Appeals & Motions
    • Voluntary Departure & CBP Home
  • Waivers
    • I-601A Provisional Waiver
    • Before Your Consular Interview
    • I-212 Permission to Reapply
    • Denied Entry to the USA
    • Canadian Rehabilitation
    • Green Card Never Valid
    • AOS with a 10-Year Bar after 212(d)(3)
    • Unlawful Presence
  • Federal Court
    • My Case Is Stuck: Can I Sue USCIS?
  • Service Area
    • Immigration Lawyer in Montana
    • Immigration Lawyer North Dakota
    • Immigration Lawyer Wyoming
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • EnglishEnglish
    • EspañolEspañol
You are here: Home / Green Card Process Montana, ND & WY / H-2A Range Workers to Green Cards: What Happens to the Monthly Wage

H-2A Range Workers to Green Cards: What Happens to the Monthly Wage

You have had the same herders on H-2A for years. They know your country, your dogs and your sheep, and you would like to keep them for good. So you ask the question every rancher in this position asks: if I sponsor them for green cards, what do I have to pay them? Most employers assume the answer is the same flat monthly range wage they pay now, with the camp and the groceries on top. It isn’t. The monthly range wage belongs to the H-2A program, and it does not carry over to the green card.

This page explains what replaces it, how big the gap really is, what you can and cannot do with housing and food, and what changes after the worker becomes a permanent resident. It is written for ranchers who employ H-2A sheepherders, goat herders and open-range livestock workers, and for the workers themselves.

What happens to the range wage when an H-2A herder gets a green card?

The short answer: the H-2A monthly range wage stops being the rule. The green card wage is the Department of Labor’s prevailing wage for the occupation and county, set from government wage survey data, and it is calculated by the hour or the year rather than by the month. Free housing and food do not count toward it. In some places, for a plainly written entry-level job, the prevailing wage comes out close to the 2026 range wage of $2,132.41 a month. Add requirements such as experience, Spanish or supervising others and it can jump by several hundred dollars a month.

Here are the three pay systems a range worker can fall under, side by side (checked November 7, 2026):

Regular H-2A farm and ranch work H-2A range herding Green card (PERM) job
How the wage is set Hourly H-2A rate (AEWR) for every hour worked Flat monthly range rate: $2,132.41 a month since February 3, 2026, adjusted every year DOL prevailing wage for the occupation and area, stated per hour or per year; can be paid as a monthly salary
Hours Every hour is paid On call up to 24 hours a day, 7 days a week Must be full-time; no upper limit
Housing and food Housing free; meals free or at a capped charge Range housing and food must be free Not credited toward the wage; you may keep providing them free
Who it covers Temporary or seasonal need Herding and production of livestock, on the range more than half the workdays A permanent, year-round job

Diagram comparing three pay systems: regular H-2A hourly pay, the H-2A monthly range wage, and the green card prevailing wage paid as a monthly salary without credit for housing or food.

The rest of this page takes each piece in turn. It does not re-teach the whole labor certification process; for that, start with our guide to the PERM prevailing wage step and the broader employment-based green card process.

Which route fits a range worker: the sheepherder rule or standard PERM?

It depends on what the worker does. The Department of Labor has a special labor certification route for sheepherders, and only sheepherders. Everyone else, including cattle and goat herders and range workers who split their time with other ranch work, goes through the standard PERM process with recruitment.

The sheepherder route (20 CFR 656.16)

Under 20 CFR 656.16, an employer can file the labor certification for a sheepherder directly with USCIS, along with the immigrant petition, instead of with the Department of Labor. There is no recruitment and no DOL review. The worker must have been “employed legally as a nonimmigrant sheepherder in the United States for at least 33 of the preceding 36 months,” and each U.S. employer who employed him as a sheepherder during those 36 months signs a letter saying so.

Three things this route does not skip:

  • A notice of filing. It must be posted at the worksite for at least 10 consecutive business days, between 30 and 180 days before filing, and it must state “a description of the job and rate of pay” (20 CFR 656.10(d)).
  • A prevailing wage. The rate on the notice has to be right, and the petition needs a prevailing wage determination. We get the determination before we post anything.
  • The paperwork itself. In one appeal the Administrative Appeals Office dismissed an employer’s challenge to the denial of a sheepherder petition that lacked the date the posted notice came down, the prevailing wage determination and the 33-of-36-month letters (AAO, Aug. 26, 2010, a non-precedent decision). The shortcut is shorter, but it is not looser.

If the worker does not meet the 33-month test, the case is not lost. The regulation says the application “may be filed under § 656.17,” the standard process. That fallback is slower and carries recruitment risk, but it is available.

Count days, not months

The 33-of-36 test sounds generous: three months of slack. In practice USCIS counts strictly. In one of our recent sheepherder cases, the worker’s single trip home inside the 36-month window ran a little over three months, because his visa appointment was delayed. USCIS denied the petition on that arithmetic alone and did not weigh the reason. So before we file, we count every day in the 36-month window that was not lawful work as a sheepherder: days outside the United States (from his I-94 travel history and passport stamps), and also any gaps between contracts or stretches spent on other work, such as cattle herding or general ranch work. The regulation counts months of lawful sheepherding, and the employer letters must say the work was lawful and continuous. If the non-qualifying time adds up to more than three months, he does not qualify yet.

Timeline of the 36 months before filing, showing at least 33 months of lawful sheepherding in the United States and no more than three months of absence in total.

A herder who is just over the line usually has a choice. He can wait until the long absence ages out of the 36-month window and then file under the sheepherder rule, or the employer can start the standard PERM now. Two things to know while waiting: every new trip home starts its own clock, and after three years in H-2A status a worker must stay outside the United States for an uninterrupted 60 days before he can be granted H-2A status again (8 CFR 214.2(h)(5)(viii)(C)). Plan that break so it does not land inside the next window.

Range workers who are not only sheepherders

The sheepherder rule is about sheep. A worker who herds cattle or goats, or who herds sheep part of the year and does other ranch work the rest, needs the standard PERM process under 20 CFR 656.17: a prevailing wage request, a recruitment campaign (a 30-day state job order, two Sunday newspaper ads and the posted notice), a 30-day wait, and then the labor certification filing with DOL. Any qualified U.S. worker who applies can defeat the application. A job that mixes range work with farm work also invites the problem we cover in the combined-duties trap for farm and ranch green cards.

How is the green card wage set for a range livestock worker?

The Department of Labor sets the green card wage from its national wage survey (the Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics data), for the occupation and the area where the work happens. Most range jobs fall under occupation 45-2093, Farmworkers, Farm, Ranch, and Aquacultural Animals. DOL issues the wage at one of four levels, and every determination starts at Level I.

To show the scale, here is Wyoming, from DOL’s wage search for 45-2093, data series July 2026 to June 2027 (FLAG wage search, checked October 30, 2026). DOL’s yearly figure is the hourly rate times 2,080 hours, rounded to the dollar; we divided it by 12 for the monthly figure.

Wyoming wage area Level I hourly Level I monthly Level II hourly Level II monthly
Western Wyoming nonmetro $11.65 $2,019.33 $14.52 $2,516.83
Eastern Wyoming nonmetro $11.97 $2,074.83 $14.67 $2,542.83
Casper metro $11.87 $2,057.50 $14.79 $2,563.58
Cheyenne metro $12.27 $2,126.83 $15.04 $2,606.92
H-2A range rate, for comparison — $2,132.41 — —

Two things jump out. At Level I, the green card wage in Wyoming is at or just below the range rate. At Level II, it is roughly $385 to $475 a month higher. Other states and counties have their own figures, so the first job in any case is to pull the numbers for the actual area of work.

What moves the wage up a level?

Under DOL’s 2009 prevailing wage guidance, the level generally rises when the job asks for more than an entry-level worker in the occupation would bring. The usual triggers on a ranch are:

  • Experience above the normal range for the occupation. H-2A herder job orders often ask for up to six months of experience, which the herding rules allow (20 CFR 655.210(b)). On a PERM, an experience requirement can add a level.
  • A language other than English. Requiring Spanish is generally treated as a special skill and usually adds a level. It also has to be justified by business necessity on the labor certification (20 CFR 656.17(h)(2)).
  • Supervising other workers, or licenses and skills beyond entry level.

The rule is not to strip out real requirements to get a lower wage. If you truly need a worker with experience, the job must say so, and the wage follows. The point is to write down only what is real, and to know before filing what each requirement costs. Our guide to the four wage levels and what raises them walks through the analysis.

Can the green card wage be paid monthly, like the range wage?

Yes. The prevailing wage comes back as an hourly or yearly figure, but the job can be offered and paid as a monthly salary, provided the salary is at least the yearly prevailing wage divided by 12. Full time for this purpose is 2,080 hours a year, which is 173.33 hours a month. (We see employers use 176 hours, which is 22 eight-hour days. That is not DOL’s 2,080-hour basis, and it produces a monthly figure slightly higher than the rule requires.) We usually advise offering a few dollars above the line so rounding never becomes an issue.

Three timing points matter as much as the number:

  • The green card wage is owed later, not now. The employer attests that the wage it pays “to begin work” in the certified job will meet the prevailing wage (20 CFR 656.10(c)(1)). For a worker already here on H-2A, that point usually comes years from now, when he has the green card or a work permit through adjustment. Until then he stays in H-2A at the H-2A rate.
  • The range rate rises every year; the PERM figure is fixed by the wage determination used for the filing. DOL adjusts the monthly range rate each year by the Employment Cost Index (20 CFR 655.211(c)). By the time the green card arrives, the gap may be smaller than it looks today, or gone.
  • You cannot recover the green card costs from the worker. The employer pays the labor certification costs, including its own attorney’s fees, and may not recoup them through “wage concessions, including deductions from wages” (20 CFR 656.12(b)).

Do free housing and food count toward the green card wage?

No. In H-2A range work, free range housing and food are part of the deal by regulation (20 CFR 655.210(c) and (e)). On a PERM, the offered wage is a cash wage that must equal or exceed DOL’s prevailing wage. In our practice housing and food are not credited against it, and USCIS has refused to count housing payments toward the offered wage (for example, Matter of C-K-B-C-, AAO July 8, 2016, a non-precedent decision). That leaves the employer three options:

  • Keep providing housing and food free. This is our recommendation. It is what the ranch does today, so it adds no new cost, and under PERM it is a benefit on top of the wage, which is allowed.
  • Charge fair-market rent only where housing is truly optional, such as a bunkhouse at headquarters when the worker could live in town.
  • Do not charge for housing and food in order to bring the worker back down to the old wage.

The third point deserves its reasons, because it is the idea employers most often raise. First, on the range, camp housing and food are not optional: a worker on call around the clock in remote country cannot decline the camp and commute, so a charge for it is a wage deduction under another name. Second, a charge priced to keep the status quo means, by design, that the worker takes home less than the certified wage, and the employer’s own pricing would be the evidence in a DOL audit, at the I-140 stage, or in a later wage claim. Third, any mandatory charge is a term of the job that would have to appear in the recruitment ads. If you are weighing how to house workers at all, our page on mobile housing for H-2A workers covers the H-2A side.

After the green card, does a flat monthly salary still work?

For a true range worker, yes. For a ranch hand who does mostly other work, maybe not, and this is the question almost no one asks until a wage claim arrives.

Once the worker is a permanent resident, he is no longer in the H-2A program, and ordinary federal wage law applies to him like any other employee. Federal law exempts from both the minimum wage and overtime any agricultural employee “principally engaged in the range production of livestock” (29 U.S.C. 213(a)(6)(E)). Put in plain terms, the Labor Department’s rules say that means the worker’s primary duty is caring for the animals on the range, or standing by to do it, away from ranch headquarters, for more than half of his time over the year (29 CFR 780.323–780.329). For a herder who lives with the band all season, a flat monthly salary at or above the green card wage meets federal law. State law can add its own rules: Colorado, for example, sets a separate weekly salary floor for range workers that it adjusts every year ($606.56 a week in 2025, which is well above the H-2A range rate).

A worker who is not principally on the range is different. Agricultural workers are still exempt from overtime (29 U.S.C. 213(b)(12)), but they are owed at least the federal minimum wage, $7.25, for every hour worked, measured week by week (29 CFR 776.4). Do the arithmetic. A monthly salary of $2,050 works out to about $473 a week (the monthly figure times 12, divided by 52, under 29 CFR 778.113(b)), which covers about 65 hours at $7.25. If a ranch hand on that salary puts in 70-hour weeks at calving or haying, the employer is below the federal minimum wage for those weeks, even though the salary meets the green card wage. The PERM wage is a floor for the job offer; it is not a substitute for paying the minimum wage on actual hours. (Federal wage law does let an employer count the reasonable cost of board and lodging it actually provides toward the minimum wage, within limits and with cost records (29 CFR 531.3 and 531.30), but that credit does nothing for the PERM wage, and the H-2A range rules forbid it while the worker is still on H-2A.)

Two qualifications. A small operation may be outside the federal minimum wage entirely: the exemption in 29 U.S.C. 213(a)(6)(A) covers employers that did not use more than 500 “man-days” of agricultural labor in any calendar quarter of the prior year. DOL says that is roughly seven full-time employees, and the range workers’ days count toward it even though they are exempt themselves (29 CFR 780.305). And state law varies. Wyoming, for example, excludes agricultural employees from its state minimum wage law altogether (Wyo. Stat. 27-4-201(a)(iv)(A)), so federal law sets the floor there; other states treat farm and ranch workers differently. The labor certification itself also requires that the job’s terms not be “contrary to Federal, state or local law” (20 CFR 656.10(c)(7)), so this is worth getting right in the job description, not just in payroll.

What if the herd crosses more than one wage area?

In our experience, the job then has to be offered at the highest prevailing wage among all the areas where the work happens, for all of the work. Range bands often summer in one county and winter in another, and DOL wage areas follow county lines. I learned this rule the hard way on an earlier PERM in which the work moved among three counties with different wages: we set it up to pay each county’s wage where the work was done, and DOL denied it. I treated that as my mistake, redid the case at the highest wage for all the work, and the second filing was certified. So the first fact we need for a range PERM is every county the herd works in, across the whole year.

Does the green card job description have to match the H-2A job orders?

It should, and it is worth reading the two side by side before you file. H-2A herding job orders must state that the workers spend more than half of their workdays on the range, and any off-range duties must be “the production of livestock,” which the rules define to include work “closely and directly related” to herding, such as fixing fences that hold the herd or caring for the herding dogs and horses (20 CFR 655.200(b)(2); 20 CFR 655.201). General ranch work does not qualify for the range procedures and belongs on a regular H-2A order at the hourly rate. A truthful PERM description of what a worker really does all year will sit in the government’s files next to the H-2A orders. If the two tell different stories, the time to notice is before filing, and the fix is to correct the H-2A side going forward, not to shade the PERM. Our page on current H-2A wage rates explains how duties change the H-2A rate for non-range work.

Does the job have to be year-round?

Yes. A labor certification is for “full-time, permanent employment” (20 CFR 656.10(c)(10)). A herding job that exists only in the grazing season, with the worker sent home for the winter, is not a PERM job. Most range operations do have year-round work: winter feeding, lambing or calving, moving camps, caring for the dogs and horses. The job description has to say what the worker does in every season. That is one reason the H-2A seasonality rules and the green card rules pull in different directions for the same employee.

How long does it take, and can the worker keep coming on H-2A while he waits?

It takes years. Most range jobs fall in EB-3 “other workers,” which the regulations define as jobs needing less than two years of training or experience (8 CFR 204.5(l)(2)). As a snapshot of where things stood when this page was written:

  • Prevailing wage: as of September 30, 2026, DOL was issuing PERM wage determinations on requests filed in June 2026 (FLAG processing times).
  • Labor certification: as of October 31, 2026, DOL’s average analyst review time was about 300 days, longer if the case is audited (same source).
  • Visa availability: on the November 2026 Visa Bulletin, the EB-3 Other Workers final action date was June 1, 2022, for Mexico and for most other countries. A priority date set in 2027 would be several years behind that cutoff.

Processing times shown are a snapshot as of the date indicated. They change often; check the linked sources for today’s figures. The sheepherder route skips the DOL steps, but not the visa line.

During the wait the worker usually keeps coming on H-2A, and that carries a real risk. H-2A is not a dual-intent visa. The State Department’s manual says that an H-2 worker’s having “sought or plans to seek permanent residence may be considered evidence” that he intends to abandon his home abroad (9 FAM 402.10-10(A)(b)). USCIS’s rule says an approved labor certification or immigrant petition will not, “standing alone,” be the basis for denying H-2 status, but it is weighed with everything else (8 CFR 214.2(h)(16)(ii)). So some consular refusals during the wait are possible, and employers should know that before they start.

One more rule is on the books. The H-2A regulation says a job will not be treated as temporary or seasonal once the same employer has filed a permanent labor certification for the same worker, or for another worker in the same position, unless the employer shows there will be at least a six-month break in U.S. employment after H-2A status ends (8 CFR 214.2(h)(5)(iv)(B)). In our experience in recent years, across the H-2A petitions we have filed while a green card case was pending, neither USCIS nor the Labor Department has raised it. We tell employers about it anyway, because a rule that is not being applied today can be applied tomorrow.

At the end, a worker who is in the United States in valid status when his date becomes current may be able to adjust status here. A worker who is home when his date comes up finishes through consular processing at the U.S. consulate in his country. With the I-140, the employer must also show it has been able to pay the offered wage since the filing date, including any gap between what the worker is actually paid during the wait and the offered wage, for every worker it has sponsored; our guide to I-140 ability to pay explains how USCIS counts that for several workers at once.

Will the Labor Department’s proposed wage rule raise the number?

It might. On March 27, 2026, DOL proposed raising all four prevailing wage levels for PERM and H-1B (91 FR 15454). As proposed, Level I would move from about the 17th percentile of the survey to about the 34th, close to today’s Level II. Comments closed May 26, 2026. As of November 7, 2026, no final rule had been published in the Federal Register. If it becomes final, a range PERM filed afterward could start near today’s Level II figure. That is a reason for an employer who has already decided to sponsor to request the wage determination sooner rather than later, but not a reason to rush a decision. We will update this paragraph when the rule moves.

What is the real cost comparison for the ranch?

The useful question is not “monthly wage now versus monthly wage later.” It is “what does it cost me each year to keep this man, before and after?”

  • Today, every year: the range rate, free housing and food, H-2A filing and recruitment costs, visa and travel costs, and agent or attorney fees, repeated every season.
  • During the wait (several years): all of that continues, plus the one-time green card costs: the wage request, recruitment ads, DOL and USCIS filings and legal fees.
  • After the green card: the green card wage (possibly close to today’s at Level I), whatever housing you choose to keep providing, and no more H-2A costs for that worker.

Against all of that sits one plain fact: a permanent resident can work for anyone. Sponsorship buys a permanent, lawful worker and ends the yearly H-2A cycle for him. It does not tie him to the ranch.

The mistakes we see most often

Most problems in range-worker green cards are set in motion before anything is filed. The common ones: assuming the H-2A range rate carries over; filing the sheepherder route on a worker whose days outside the country were never counted; writing a PERM job description that does not match what the H-2A orders say; offering one county’s wage for a herd that works three; and planning to charge for the camp to make the numbers work. Each of these is avoidable if the job is written from what the worker actually does, every county is listed, and the wage is pulled before the employer commits.

I have practiced immigration law since 1996 and founded Immigration Law of Montana, P.C. in 2001. The firm has helped ranchers across Montana, Wyoming and North Dakota move long-time H-2A workers to green cards, including sheepherders under the special rule. If you are thinking about sponsoring your range workers, contact us before the wage request goes in. Our guide to immigration for farmers and ranchers covers the rest of the agricultural picture, and our page on the sheepherder green card summarizes the special route.

Footer

Our Location

We are located about 20 minutes NE of Billings in a rural community:

Immigration Law of Montana, P.C.
8400 Clark Rd
Shepherd, MT 59079
406-373-9828

Affiliations

Montana State Bar

AILA Member

 

Social

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Tumblr
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Immigration Lawyer Montana
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms of Service
  • Site Map
  • Contact Us

COPYRIGHT © 2026 Immigration Law of Montana · All Rights Reserved

  • EnglishEnglish
  • EspañolEspañol