• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Immigration Law of Montana

Christopher J. Flann, Attorney

406-373-9828
  • Make an Appointment
  • Client Log In
  • Home

Immigration Law of Montana

  • About
    • How to Read Immigration Lawyer Reviews
    • Christopher Flann, Attorney
    • Collette Layton, Legal Assistant
    • Rockwell “Rock” Hinkle, Legal Assistant
    • Reviews and Testimonials
    • Gabriela Veroes Legal Assistant
    • Maryangel Aguilera Legal Assistant
    • Fidel Villegas, Legal Assistant
    • Gabriel Chávez, Legal Assistant
  • US Citizenship
    • Form N-648 Medical Disability Exception
    • Age-Based English Waivers
    • N-600 vs Passport for Citizenship Proof
    • INA 320 — Automatic Citizenship
    • Stepchild Adoption and Citizenship
    • Citizenship through Adoption
    • Citizenship through Naturalization
    • The 3-Year Rule for Spouses
    • When the 3-Year Clock Starts
    • Separation and the 3-Year Rule
    • Citizenship through Military
    • Derivative US Citizenship
    • Child Born Abroad: Check Citizenship Before the I-130
    • N-600K — Citizenship Through a Grandparent
    • INA 301 & 309 — Citizenship at Birth Abroad
  • Green Cards
    • I-130 Separate Petitions for LPRs
    • Income Requirements with Stepchildren
    • AOS with 10-Year Bar (212(d)(3))
    • I-751 Waiver After Divorce
    • Refugee Travel Document Expired
    • Protecting Asylum / SIJS Benefits
    • Asylee Adjustment: INA 209 vs 245
    • NVC Document Roadblocks
    • 221(g) Refusal Explained
    • F-2B Election (Parent Naturalizes)
    • VAWA for Cuban Adjustment Act Derivatives
    • Lying on Form I-485
    • Adjustment of Status: Getting Your Green Card Without Leaving the United States
    • Health and the Public Charge Test
    • Asylee Green Card
    • Conditional Green Card Renewal: Removing Conditions With Form I-751
    • Employment Based Green Card
    • O-1 to a Green Card
    • I-140 Ability to Pay
    • Ability to Pay After a Loss Year
    • Consular Processing
    • Family Based Green Card
    • Green Card for Religious Worker
    • Green Card through Marriage
    • Green Card through Refugee or Asylee Status
    • Parole in Place for Military Families (2026): Who Qualifies, How to Apply, and What It Costs
    • Green Card Renewal: Complete I-90 Guide
    • Humanitarian Green Card
    • Refugee Green Card
    • Sheepherder Green Card
    • H-2A Range Workers to Green Cards
    • Marrying an Illegal Immigrant
    • For American Indians Born in Canada
    • Special Immigrant Visa
    • When Your LPR Spouse Dies
    • When Your USC Spouse Dies
    • Derivative Beneficiaries When Petitioners Die
  • Immigration Guides
    • Lying on Immigration Forms
    • PERM: Education + Experience
    • The EB-4 Visa Problem
    • Rights of Filipino Teachers and Workers
    • Canadian Immigration Pathways
    • Immigration for Employers
    • EB-5 Investor Visa Guide
    • Immigration for Farmers and Ranchers
    • Immigration for Religious Organizations
    • Farm Worker Green Cards
  • US Visas
    • J-1 Exchange Visitor Visa
      • J-1 Intern & Trainee Year
      • J-1 Summer Work Travel
      • J-1 Au Pair Program
      • J-1 Two-Year Home-Residency Rule
      • J-1 Waivers
      • Conrad 30 for J-1 Physicians
      • J-1 Advisory Opinion
      • After Your J-1 Year
      • J-1 or F-1 for Married Students
    • B-1 for Religious Work
    • Performer Visa Requirements
    • Options After Parole Termination
    • Asylum: Complete Application Guide
    • Asylum for Visa Waiver Program Entrants
    • Withdrawing a Preparer-Filed Asylum Application
    • F-1 & OPT
      • STEM OPT Extension Guide
      • OPT Guide for F-1 Students
    • E-Series Visas
      • E-3 Job Ended: Your Options
      • E-2 Business Changes
      • E-2 Visa for Canadians
      • E-1 Visa for Treaty Traders
      • E-2 Visa for Treaty Investors
        • The E-2 Active-Investment Standard
        • E-2 Investor: You or Your Company?
        • L-1A New Office to EB-1C Green Card
        • E-2 Renewal RFE and Deference
      • E-3 Visa for Australian Professionals
    • H-1B Repayment Agreements
    • TN Catch-All Categories
    • The B-2 Visitor Visa: A Practical Guide
    • B-1 Visa for Business Visitors
    • H-1B Visa for Specialty Occupation Workers
      • H-1B Visa Lottery
      • H-1B for School Districts
        • Cap exemption for school districts
        • Teacher job descriptions and RFEs
      • H-1B Cap-Gap & OPT
    • H-2A Program
      • H-2A Wage Rates
      • H-2A Job Service Referrals
      • DUI and the H-2A Visa
      • Canadian Custom Combine Crews (H-2A)
      • H-2A Mobile Housing
      • H-2A Workers Staying Longer
      • H-2A Ended, Asylum Pending: Working in the Gap
      • Becoming an H-2A Labor Contractor
      • H-2A Seasonality Requirements
    • H-2B Visa Guide: Cap, Lottery, and Temporary Need
    • H-3 Visa for Trainees and Special Education Visitors
    • K-1 Visa
      • K-1 and Expedited Removal
      • K-1 Meeting Waiver
      • K-1 with Criminal Record
    • K-3 Spouse Visa
    • O-1 Visa for Artists, Scientists, Educators, Businesspeople and Athletes
    • P-3 Visa: A Guide to Culturally Unique Programs
    • R-1 Visa for Religious Workers
    • R-1 Five-Year Limit: Recapturing Time
    • TN Visa: Work Authorization Under USMCA
    • Canadian Nurse Practitioners on a TN
    • U Visa for Crime Victims: What It Takes and What to Expect
    • T Visa for Trafficking Victims
    • Change of Nonimmigrant Status
    • Form I-539 (2026): Extending or Changing Your Nonimmigrant Status
    • Process for US Visa Application Through Admission and Stay
    • Entry into United States
    • I-94 Admission Record: What Controls Your Stay
    • CBP Travel History Shows Trips You Never Took
    • Refused Re-Entry After a Canada Trip
    • Volunteer Visa USA
    • Humanitarian Parole: Programs, Termination & Options
    • Leaving the United States
  • Immigration Services
    • Premium Processing Eligibility
    • How to Withdraw a Pending USCIS Application
    • RFE Response Help in Montana: When Immigration Requests Can Be Fixed (And When They Can’t)
    • Apostille Services
    • Document Translation Services
    • Picked Up by ICE in Montana: What to Do, Where They Will Be Held, and What Comes Next
    • Why A Strategy Consultation
  • Removal Defense
    • Removal Proceedings Overview
    • Picked Up by ICE in Montana
    • Detention & Bond Hearings
    • Get Your Immigration Court Records
    • Get Your USCIS Records
    • Pull Your Criminal Record
    • Criminal Records & Immigration Status
    • Everyday Offenses
    • Cancellation of Removal
      • Non-LPR Cancellation
      • VAWA Cancellation
      • BIA Ends Easy LPR Cancellation
    • Withholding of Removal
    • Convention Against Torture (CAT)
    • Country Conditions Expert
    • Adjustment of Status in Immigration Court
    • SIJS Green Card in Immigration Court
    • Marriage During Removal Proceedings
    • Green Card Never Valid
    • In Absentia Removal Orders
    • Appeals & Motions
    • Voluntary Departure & CBP Home
  • Waivers
    • I-601A Provisional Waiver
    • Before Your Consular Interview
    • I-212 Permission to Reapply
    • Denied Entry to the USA
    • Canadian Rehabilitation
    • Green Card Never Valid
    • AOS with a 10-Year Bar after 212(d)(3)
    • Unlawful Presence
  • Federal Court
    • My Case Is Stuck: Can I Sue USCIS?
  • Service Area
    • Immigration Lawyer in Montana
    • Immigration Lawyer North Dakota
    • Immigration Lawyer Wyoming
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • EnglishEnglish
    • EspañolEspañol

H-2A

150 H-2A Applications in Your Inbox: Which Ones Count?

November 20, 2026 by Admin-ILM

Cattle are sorted through a corral alley into separate pens under a wide Montana sky.

Employers who file for H-2A workers tell us the same thing, in nearly the same words: “I have 150 emails in my inbox. Do I have to look at any of these, or can I just hire the person I want?” Usually the caller already has a worker in mind, often a man who has worked the place before. The emails are a side effect of a change most employers never heard about: since a 2019 rule, the main public advertisement for every H-2A job is a Department of Labor website, and people around the world read it.

The short answer (checked November 9, 2026). You have to sort the inbox, not answer all of it. Every applicant who is a U.S. worker (a citizen, a permanent resident, a refugee or asylee, or anyone else who can already work in your job without you filing anything) must be considered, offered the job if qualified and available, and listed with a disposition in your recruitment report. Everyone else in the inbox, including foreign workers who would need you to file for them, you may pass over, or keep for next year. And because the government now advertises your job for you, in our experience (as of November 2026) most employers no longer need a recruiter just to find a worker.

Decision chart for sorting H-2A job applications: is the applicant already authorized to work in this job without the employer filing anything? If yes, a U.S. worker who must be considered, hired if qualified and available, and listed on the recruitment report; if no, the employer may pass over the application or keep it for a future petition.

Why is my H-2A job on a government website?

Because DOL is required to post it, and since 2019 that posting has replaced the newspaper. DOL has had to post H-2A job orders on an electronic job registry since its 2010 rules. Until October 21, 2019, an H-2A employer also had to run a newspaper advertisement in the area of employment as part of its recruitment of U.S. workers. The Department of Labor’s final rule of September 20, 2019, Modernizing Recruitment Requirements for the Temporary Employment of H-2A Foreign Workers in the United States (84 FR 49439), removed the newspaper requirement and expanded the electronic registry; the old advertising sections are now reserved. Today, when DOL accepts an application it posts the job order “for public examination” on its electronic job registry and keeps it there until the end of the recruitment period (20 CFR 655.144).

That registry is SeasonalJobs.dol.gov. DOL says it launched in December 2018, works on a phone, and offers job listings in Spanish. (The Spanish is machine-translated by Microsoft Translator, and the site itself tells readers to check the English original.) The site also publishes data feeds so that commercial job boards can repost every listing, which is why your job may turn up on websites you have never heard of.

Do I still need an agent or recruiter to find H-2A workers?

For most employers, no. The registry was built to show U.S. workers the job. Because it is public, it also shows the job to anyone, anywhere, who is looking for farm work in the United States, and that changed the order of operations. Before the registry, an employer found a worker first, usually through a paid agency, and then filed. Now an employer files, and applicants find the job. Agencies used to sell exactly that search, often as a placement fee plus a monthly charge through the contract. An employer willing to read the applications and hold a few video calls can now do that part itself.

The other channel is older than any website: workers recommend workers. In our experience, the pattern repeats in small towns across the region. One H-2A worker comes to a ranch outside a town of a few hundred people and does well. By the next season, neighboring ranches that have never used the program are asking him whether he has a brother, a cousin or a friend at home. One hire becomes three or four, and none of them came through an agent.

Whether you used a recruiter matters on one government form. The H-2A section of the USCIS petition, Form I-129, asks whether you used or plan to use “an agent, facilitator, staff, recruiter, or similar employment service” to locate or recruit the H-2A workers, and if so, to list every such person or entity, here or abroad (Form I-129, H Classification Supplement, Section 2, Items 6–7 (edition 09/09/26)). A worker who tells a friend about the job is not an employment service. A paid intermediary anywhere in the chain may be, and the answer has to be accurate.

Which of these applicants do I have to consider?

Every U.S. worker, and only U.S. workers. The job must stay open “to any qualified U.S. worker,” and rejections of U.S. workers must be “only for lawful, job-related reasons” (20 CFR 655.135(a)). The regulation defines a U.S. worker as a citizen or national; a permanent resident, refugee, asylee, or other immigrant authorized to work; or “an individual who is not an unauthorized alien … with respect to the employment in which the worker is engaging” (20 CFR 655.103(b)).

The last part of that definition is the practical test. An applicant is a U.S. worker if he can already lawfully take your job without you doing anything for him. That includes citizens, permanent residents, refugees and asylees, and people with an employment authorization document that is not tied to one employer, such as many people with Temporary Protected Status or a pending asylum case. It does not include an H-2A worker who is employed on another ranch today: his permission to work is tied to that employer, so with respect to your job he is not authorized until a petition is filed for him, and no employer has to file one. (Since January 17, 2025, an eligible H-2A worker already in the United States may start work for a new employer once that employer properly files a nonfrivolous H-2A petition for him (or on the requested start date, if later), 8 CFR 214.2(h)(2)(i)(I). That is still the new employer’s filing, so it does not make him a U.S. worker in your inbox.)

Two questions sort the inbox lawfully, and we recommend asking every applicant both, in the same words:

  1. Are you currently authorized to work in the United States?
  2. Will you now or in the future require the employer to take any action, such as filing a visa petition, to keep you authorized to work?

The Justice Department office that enforces the immigration anti-discrimination law has said, in technical assistance letters, that an employer that asks all applicants whether they will require sponsorship now or in the future, and declines those who do, “would likely not violate” that law (letter of June 15, 2016; see also its 2010 letter). Those letters are guidance, not binding rulings. What the questions must never become is a screen against people the law protects: a permanent resident, refugee or asylee answers “yes” to the first question and “no” to the second, and is a U.S. worker you must consider. The H-2A rule itself forbids rejecting a U.S. worker because of citizenship status (20 CFR 655.135(a)).

Everyone who needs you to file something (most of the foreign applicants in the inbox) you may pass over. Many employers keep the best of those emails for a future season.

What do I owe the U.S. workers in the inbox?

The same thing you owe a worker the state job service sends you: contact, consideration, a job offer if they are qualified and available, and a written record. The employer must “consider all U.S. applicants” and “accept and hire all applicants who are qualified and who will be available” (20 CFR 655.135(c)(3)). If you require interviews, you must hold them by phone or near where the worker is, and you may not give H-2A candidates easier treatment in interviews than U.S. applicants (20 CFR 655.135(c)(2)). If you video-call your preferred foreign candidate, call the U.S. applicant too.

The qualifications you use must be the ones in the job order, applied the same way to everyone. Our page on what to do when the job service refers U.S. workers to your H-2A job walks through how to contact and interview a U.S. applicant, the reasons for turning one down that hold up and the ones that do not, and why withdrawing the application does not end the obligation. The same rules apply to a U.S. worker who writes to you from SeasonalJobs.dol.gov.

How long do I have to keep considering U.S. applicants?

At least until your H-2A workers leave for your farm, and for many employers until half the contract has run. Positive recruitment ends on the date the H-2A workers depart for the place of employment, which the rule presumes is the third day before the first date of need (20 CFR 655.158). The job order stays on the registry until the end of the recruitment period (20 CFR 655.144(b)).

After the workers depart, the 50 percent rule requires the employer to hire any qualified, eligible U.S. worker who applies until 50 percent of the contract period has passed (20 CFR 655.135(d)). That rule does not apply to every employer. The 50 percent rule does not apply to an employer that certifies that, in every calendar quarter of the preceding calendar year, it used no more than 500 man-days of agricultural labor; that it is not an employer-member of an association that filed for its members; and that it has not otherwise associated with other employers who are petitioning for H-2A workers. In our experience, many family ranches in Montana fit that exemption. A larger operation, or a member of an association, usually does not, and for that employer a U.S. worker who applies in the middle of the season still has to be hired if qualified.

Some employers also owe more recruitment than the registry. Where DOL has designated other states as traditional or expected sources of labor for your area, the notice accepting your application will say what additional positive recruitment you must do there (20 CFR 655.154). Read that part of the notice; it is not the same for every state or every year.

What do I have to write down?

A recruitment report that accounts for every U.S. worker who applied. The employer must prepare, sign and date a written report that names each recruitment source and, for “each U.S. worker who applied or was referred to the job opportunity,” gives the worker’s name and contact information and the disposition, with the lawful job-related reason for anyone not hired. The report must be updated until the end of the recruitment period and kept for audit (20 CFR 655.156). This is the real answer to the 150-email question: you have to read the inbox far enough to find the U.S. workers, because each one has to appear on that report.

Two more records belong in the same file. You must contact your U.S. workers from the previous year in the same occupation and invite them back, unless they were fired for cause or abandoned the job and you gave DOL timely notice, and you must keep proof of that contact (20 CFR 655.153). And everything (recruitment proof, the report, résumés and contact information) must be kept for 3 years (20 CFR 655.167).

What does this change, and what doesn’t it?

The search for an H-2A worker has largely stopped being something an employer has to buy. The legal test behind the registry has not changed at all. The website that brings you a hundred foreign applicants is the same website that brings you the occasional U.S. worker, and that worker has a claim on the job that your preferred candidate does not. The employers who get into trouble are not the ones who hire from the inbox. They are the ones who never looked through it for U.S. workers.

If you have an inbox to sort and a worker already in mind, talk to us before the recruitment report is due. Immigration Law of Montana, P.C. files H-2A applications for farms and ranches in Montana, North Dakota and Wyoming. Our overview of the H-2A program covers the full process, our H-2A wage guide covers what you must pay, and our guide to PERM labor certification shows the contrast: a green-card sponsor still has to buy newspaper advertisements.

Filed Under: Blog, H-2A & Farm Labor Tagged With: farm labor, H-2A, H-2A recruitment, recruitment report, SeasonalJobs, U.S. worker

Footer

Our Location

We are located about 20 minutes NE of Billings in a rural community:

Immigration Law of Montana, P.C.
8400 Clark Rd
Shepherd, MT 59079
406-373-9828

Affiliations

Montana State Bar

AILA Member

 

Social

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Tumblr
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Immigration Lawyer Montana
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms of Service
  • Site Map
  • Contact Us

COPYRIGHT © 2026 Immigration Law of Montana · All Rights Reserved

  • EnglishEnglish
  • EspañolEspañol